Tuesday, May 20, 2014 at 08:23
I think the Inreach is a little more than just a tracking device, as it allows you to send & receive messages. I don't think SPOT offers this & I don't know about the yellowbrick system.
I see any system that is used (tracking device or sat
phone) as an emergency device only, I wouldn't think it would be used to have long discussions with the kids as to why the dog got out back at
home, etc. Your normal
phone in a receiving area will cover those conversations.
A few have mentioned the fact that you can't have a voice to voice conversation with the Inreach system, while this is true, but what if your emergency did not allow you have a verbal conversation? e.g. Say your accident gave you a broken jaw?
With a Sat
Phone, do you know exactly where you are, to direct the emergency service team?
The tracking device systems appear to have one distinct advantage over Sat Phones that I can see, you can send a SOS alert (life threatening emergencies only) to a 24/7/365 monitored office that will instantly have the coordinates of where you are & will start to alert the local response, all this without any other electronic or verbal conversation. On Inreach they will confirm message has been received.
The Inreach system also allows you to send SMS or emails (all messages have your location data attached) to others for this & general non-emergency situations, that would allow a bit more detail.
I am not saying which one is better, as I don't know & I have neither, I am researching for my big trip next year & the (good) trouble is, there are so many options to look at & review.
Thanks
FollowupID:
816101